From COVID 19 to the Black Death: Lessons from History
While staying at home in 2020, I encountered a pervasive sense of fear, a feeling unlike anything I had known before. Yet, this was not the first time in human history that such an event had occurred. Six hundred and seventy three years earlier, in 1347, Europe faced a similarly terrifying ordeal. However, that event was far deadlier than COVID 19. Known in history as the Black Death, the plague claimed the lives of approximately one third of Europe's population.
The COVID 19 pandemic gave me a new perspective on the Black Death. Port closures, quarantines, misinformation, vaccine hesitancy, and the daily tracking of death tolls, all these elements helped me grasp the fear and uncertainty experienced by the people of 14th century Europe. In this article, I explore the origins of the Black Death, the societal reactions to it, and how Europe rebuilt itself in its aftermath, all from a personal perspective.
From Lockdown to Desolation: Ships Arriving at the Port of Messina in 1347 and the Initial Spread
The mechanism of transmission was simple yet deadly. The disease was caused by the bacterium Yersinia pestis. This bacterium lived in the bodies of black rats, and their fleas (Xenopsylla cheopis) transmitted the disease to humans. Black rats disembarking from the ships made their way into the city's densely populated areas, further spreading the disease.
The disease manifested in several forms. In the form initially known as bubonic plague, painful swellings, known as buboes, appeared in the patient's armpits and groin. When the lungs became infected, it developed into pneumonic plague, leading to rapid death accompanied by the coughing up of blood. It was so lethal that some patients died within a matter of days or even hours.
The mortality rate was alarmingly high. Historians estimate that approximately one third of Europe's population perished. In some cities, the death toll reached 80 to 90 percent of the population. In England alone, the population was reduced by more than half within a century, and around 1,000 villages were abandoned.
During the COVID 19 pandemic, measures such as closing ports, imposing travel bans, and implementing quarantines were adopted. However, in 1347, such measures were impossible to implement because there was no basic scientific understanding of the nature of the disease.
Fear, Speculation, and Fake News: Social Responses in the 14th Century and Today
Violence against the Jewish community was widespread at the time, as people accused Jews of poisoning wells. By 1349, Jewish populations in many cities across Germany and the Netherlands had been decimated. Although Pope Clement VI condemned the violence against Jews, his papal bulls proved ineffective.
The Flagellant movement was an extremist religious movement driven by those who believed the disease was a punishment from God. They marched through cities, whipping themselves and publicly confessing their sins. This movement originated in Austria or Hungary in 1348 and spread to Germany.
The miasma theory is the belief that disease spreads through contaminated air. This theory, attributed to Galen, was accepted for centuries. People believed that vapors rising from volcanoes and earthquakes, as well as the foul odors emanating from refuse heaps and corpses, caused disease.
The concept of quarantine originated during this period. In 1377, the city of Ragusa, modern day Dubrovnik, began isolating ships and passengers arriving from disease stricken areas for 40 days. The word "quarantine" is derived from the Italian phrase "quaranta giorni," meaning forty days.
The fake news, misinformation spread via social media, and fears regarding vaccines that we encountered during the COVID 19 era are modern day echoes of 14th century superstitions.
How the World Rebuilt Itself: Socio Economic Transformations in Post Black Death Europe
The weakening of the feudal system was a long term consequence. The scarcity of human labor forced landowners to retain their peasants, while many peasants gained the ability to alter their working conditions or abandon the land altogether. According to research by Mark Bailey, landowners began reducing the most onerous service obligations as early as the mid 1350s.
The Peasants' Revolt of 1381 marked the first large scale social uprising in English history. The rebellion was triggered by government attempts to cap workers' wages and the imposition of taxes. Thousands of peasants marched on London and briefly seized control of the city. Although the uprising was suppressed, it accelerated the collapse of the feudal system.
Questioning the Power of the Church
A profound shift occurred within the religious sphere. When the Church proved unable to halt the disease, public faith waned. People began to question the Church's power and influence and openly criticize certain of its practices. This paved the way for the subsequent Reformation movement.
Quarantine emerged as a singular scientific innovation in the fields of medicine and public health. Medieval medicine had previously relied on astronomy, superstition, and ineffective treatments such as bloodletting.
Changes in vernacular languages and art had profound cultural consequences. An obsession with death manifested in art forms such as the "Dance of Death." Skeletal figures, decomposing corpses, and somber religious themes became prominent features of the art of the time.
In the wake of COVID 19, a phenomenon known as the "Great Resignation" saw hundreds of thousands of workers changing jobs. This mirrors the way peasants abandoned their lands in search of better opportunities following the Black Death. Both the decline of labor and the increase in workers' power represent a pattern that has historically recurred time and again.
Conclusion
The COVID 19 pandemic compelled me to look back at history. The Black Death was not only the most devastating human tragedy of the 14th century but also the catalyst for a social transformation that forever altered the face of Europe. The collapse of the feudal system, the rise of worker power, the questioning of the Church's authority, and the inception of public health measures like quarantine, all these factors contributed to shaping the modern world.
While a pandemic devastates a society, it also compels it to rebuild. This is the lesson history teaches us: humanity faces the same challenges across eras, and the only way to overcome them is through science, cooperation, and empathy.
References
. Black Death and its implication on history
2. Ziegler, P. (2013). The Black Death. Faber & Faber
3. The Middle Ages: The Black Death (Britannica LaunchPacks)
4. Flagellants and persecution of Jews during the Black Death
5. Miasma theory and quarantine origins
6. Labor shortage, wages, and decline of serfdom
7. Bailey, M. (2021). After the Black Death: Economy, Society, and the Law in Fourteenth-Century England. Oxford University Press
8. Peasants' Revolt of 1381
9. Decline of Church authority
10. Art and cultural responses (Dance of Death)
11. COVID-19 and labor market transformation (RAND)